Casa Mahalo – 5235U

House in Siesta Key

Casa Mahalo – 5235U

House in Siesta Key
Property is not available for the selected dates
Check In Select Date
Check Out Select Date

Stay Information

  • From: $360 per night

Property Details

This home could qualify for our BookCareFree promotion for 2021 arrivals
This includes:
• Lenient Cancellation Policies
• Deferred Payments
• Adjusted Deposit Amounts
Ask us about how you can qualify for this special offer!

We go above and beyond the industry standard for cleanings with our multi-tiered cleaning protocol. We have improved and strengthened our cleaning crews by mandating the highest quality products that are EPA approved to use against COVID-19. Our cleaners also have a longer period of time to complete this thorough process to ensure a full cleaning of all items. After this initial cleaning, we require the cleaning company manager to assess the job completed and assign any additional areas to be cleaned. Furthermore, right before your arrival, we have a quality control team that conducts a 50-point pre arrival inspection on this home and reapplies the approved products once again right before your walk into your beautiful home. We extensively re-clean every light switch, lamp, door knob, surface, remote, hard back chair, and any area that is considered a high volume touch surface with approved disinfectant cleaning material. This allows you to vacation worry free regarding the cleanliness of your home and truly relax as soon as you arrive. Our cleaning services have enhanced protocols in place to ensure that you feel tremendously safe and happy with this amazing home. Our goal is to have you feel like you are walking into a brand new vacation home that no one has ever stayed at before!

This home is a part of a duplex unit, meaning that it could share a dividing wall, floor, ceiling, outdoor space, and/or amenities with another unit(s). Contact us directly for more information regarding any shared space for this vacation home.

This luxurious and recently constructed (completion date of June 2017) 4 bedroom/3 bathroom home offers all of the amenities for your vacation, including a private heated pool and outdoor cabana room! Casa Mahalo is centrally located in the heart of Siesta Key Village and just a short walk to world famous Siesta Key Beach, voted the # 1 beach in the USA! This home is ideal for families and large groups.

Casa Mahalo can accommodate up to 12 guests with a bedding configuration as follows:

• Bedroom # 1: King Bed (1) - Sleeps: 2 + 1 Chair Sleeper Sofa (1) - Sleeps: 1
• Bedroom # 2: King Bed (1) - Sleeps: 2 + 1 Chair Sleeper Sofa (1) - Sleeps: 1
• Bedroom # 3: King Bed (1) - Sleeps: 2
• Bedroom # 4: Queen Bed (1) - Sleeps: 2
• Extra: Queen Sleeper Sofa (1) - Sleeps: 2

Exclusive Amenities include:

• Private Heated Pool
• Private Elevator
• Stainless Steel Appliances
• Linens Provided
• Regular Coffee Maker
• Washer/Dryer in Unit
• Kitchen Essentials Provided
• Dishwasher
• Flat Screen HDTVs throughout
• Outdoor Cabana Room
• Outdoor Dining Area
• Outdoor Lounge Area
• Beach Towels
• Beach Caddy
• Grill
• Beach Cooler
• Outdoor Flat Screen HDTV
• Bikes (4)
• Outdoor Refrigerator
• Access to The Black Pearl Pontoon Boat Rental (exclusive to The Cottages guests’ only!)
• Free WiFi
• Dog-Friendly with a Fee (1 dog up to 25 lbs.)

Sleeping Arrangements

Common Spaces

1 Sofa Bed

Bedroom 1

1 King Bed, 1 Single Bed

Bedroom 2

1 King Bed, 1 Single Bed

Bedroom 3

1 King Bed

Bedroom 4

1 Queen Bed



  • Concierge - Other Services


  • Bay
  • Coin Laundry
  • Health Beauty Spa
  • Marina
  • Museums
  • Parks
  • Water Parks
  • Winery Tours
  • Zoo


  • Satellite / Cable
  • Television


  • Central Heat
  • Clothes Dryer
  • Elevator
  • Garage
  • Hair Dryer
  • Heating
  • Internet - Hi Speed
  • Internet - Wireless
  • Iron and Board
  • King Bed
  • Linens Provided
  • Living Room
  • Parking
  • Towels Provided
  • Washing Machine


  • Coffee Maker
  • Cookware
  • Dining Area
  • Dining Spices
  • Dishes & Utensils
  • Dishwasher
  • Kitchen
  • Microwave
  • Oven
  • Refrigerator
  • Stove
  • Toaster


  • Antiquing
  • Bird Watching
  • Boating
  • Eco Tourism
  • Gambling
  • Horseback Riding
  • Outlet Shopping
  • Paddle Boat
  • Shopping
  • Water Sports
  • Wildlife Viewing


  • Hospital
  • Laundromat


  • Beach
  • Near Ocean
  • Town
  • Village


  • Balcony
  • Bicycle
  • Deck/Patio
  • Gas Grill


  • Heated Pool
  • Private Pool


  • Fire Extinguisher
  • First Aid Kit
  • Outdoor Lighting


  • Basketball Court
  • Biking
  • Deep Sea Fishing
  • Fishing
  • Fishing Bay
  • Fishing Fly
  • Fishing Surf
  • Golf Optional
  • Golfing
  • Hiking
  • Hot Air Ballooning
  • Jet Skiing
  • Kayaking
  • Paragliding
  • Parasailing
  • Pier Fishing
  • Racquetball
  • Roller Blading
  • Sailing
  • Scuba or Snorkeling
  • Snorkeling
  • Surfing
  • Swimming
  • Tennis
  • Water Skiing
  • Water Tubing
  • Wind Surfing


  • Family
  • Historic
  • Luxury
  • Romantic



5235 Calle Menorca
Siesta Key, Florida


Cancellation Policy

CANCELLATION POLICY / TRIP INSURANCE NOTICE: Regarding this reservation process, The Cottages on the Key Company is creating a legal, binding contract between the property owner and the guests to insure the desired benefits to each of the parties. The Cancellation Policy for prime season rentals [December – April, June-August] stipulates that any rental deposit amount and any additional payments made are refundable less any administrative fees up to ninety [90] days prior to the beginning of the rental period. After 90 days prior to the rental period, the Licensor shall have the uncontested right to retain the initial Deposit and any other payments received. If you cancel and your check-in date is more than ninety [90] days away, you will receive a refund of your deposit less the administrative fee by credit card refund within 15 days of your written cancellation notice. The Cancellation Policy for all other reservations in the periods of September – November, and May stipulates that any rental deposit amount and any payments are refundable less any administrative fees up to seven [7] days prior to the beginning of the rental period. After 7 days prior to the rental period, the Licensor shall have the uncontested right to retain the initial Deposit and any other payments received. The Cottages on the Key company strongly recommends purchasing a TRIP INSURANCE POLICY to insure recovery of your deposit/payments made and potentially retained by this Cancellation Policy to avoid loss during unforeseen circumstances. We recommend researching trip insurance companies online. We also offer an option of purchasing trip insurance at the time of your booking with The Cottages on the Key upon request. Guests may also purchase the trip insurance up to 24 hours prior to their arrival. Please note: there is an option for cancelling for any reason (CFAR) up to 20 days within the initial deposit date. We would recommend you research this type of policy from various providers to include iTravelInsured:

Please note: if you booked using a 3rd party affiliate (i.e. HomeAway or VRBO), please refer to their cancellation policy for your records.

Deposit Policy

Please sign online with digital signature. This agreement must be returned to us within 48 hours, as we cannot guarantee your requested dates without receipt of a signed rental agreement. In order to finalize your reservation, we require the initial deposit plus a credit card on file to cover any incidentals and negligent damages.

17 Guest Reviews

5 star


4 star


3 star


2 star


1 star


"We stayed at Casa Mahalo and had a great experience. The house was clean and staff very helpful of we ever had any questions. The house was walking distance to everything, the beach, shops, grocery, dinning, etc. Anything you needed was only a couple minute walk or there are bikes in the garage. Pool was nice and heated. Beds were comfortable and plenty of blankets and extra linens if needed. I would definitely book through them again."

by Luciana


We stayed at Casa Mahalo and had a great experience. The house was clean and staff very helpful of we ever had any questions. The house was walking distance to everything, the beach, shops, grocery, dinning, etc. Anything you needed was only a couple minute walk or there are bikes in the garage. Pool was nice and heated. Beds were comfortable and plenty of blankets and extra linens if needed. I would definitely book through them again.

"The home was beautiful! The walk to the ocean was easy. My family had a wonderful week."

by Kathy Peterson


The home was beautiful! The walk to the ocean was easy. My family had a wonderful week.

"Awesome Property!"

by Brandi F.


We had a great time at this property! It was perfect for a girls getaway and the private pool is an awesome amenity! We had some issues with the elevator (user error) but ended up just not using it anyways. The property was beautiful inside and out and really conveniently located. We have recommended this property to all our friends and do plan to come back ASAP!

"Great property in a wonderful location"

by Brandey E.


This home was the perfect size. It was clean and so easy to check-in. The gourmet cupcake welcome gift was such a pleasant surprise and our son especially enjoyed them! When we had one problem with the lock, someone responded immediately and was at the house within minutes. Our favorite part of the home was the location. We were able to walk to the market, restaurants, and shops. I would defintely stay here again!

"Great family vacation"

by Matt R.


This place is beautiful and in a great location. Close to the restaurants, shops and bars and just minutes away from the beach. Walking into the home we were greeted with a baked good surprise and the house was very clean. We brought 4 teenagers with us so the bicycles were great for them to ride to shops and the beach. We will be renting from you again soon.

"Casa Mahalo, Siesta Key"

by David S.


The property was superb. In particular, I wish I could give the location 6 or 7 stars. It was a two minute walk to the beach and less than that to all of the activity in Siesta Key Village, as well as the incredibly well stocked Morton's Siesta Key market. The layout of the apartment gave each couple in our group of 8 plenty of privacy as well as plenty of room to socialize and eat together. Minor in the overall scheme of things was the limited water pressure in the showers, particularly the master bath. Overall I can't recommend this property highly enough, and look forward to returning in the future.

"Siesta key cottage"

by Kelly F.


This house was PERFECT for my best friends bachelorette. There were 9 of us. An abundance of towels. The pool was a great size. The king size beds were super comfortable and the sofa sleeper that pulled out came in handy. There were 2 instances where someone got stuck in the elevator for a few seconds, we had to open and shut the gate a few times from the inside to get the outside door to open. Maybe that needs to be figured out before the next guest. Other than that it was a beautiful home and I HIGHLY suggest it to anyone. The walk to the beach seemed like a 3 minute walk and the water was see-through and the sand was so silky.

"Beautiful place, great location"

by Courtney F.


This place was perfect for our girls getaway! The location was perfect! Walking distance to all the shops, restaurants, and the beach. My only complaints are that we could’ve get the elevator to work after the first day, the ice machine did not work on the kitchen refrigerator, and there were ants in one of the bedrooms/bathrooms. Other than those things we had a great time and would definitely come back!

"Casa Mahalo"

by Susan C.


Our group visited Siesta Key August 2019 for the first time. We had a great time and really enjoyed our rental Casa Mahalo. It was situated close to the beach and the village. Everything you possibly could need was within walking distance. Rent a golf cart and you do not need to bring a car. The home was very comfortable and nicely decorated. The mattresses were very much so we tried to find the manufacturer name on the mattress:) The pool was great to come home to after a hot day at the beach. The elevator was a nice perk to get our luggage and bags to the second level...and to get tired bodies up to bed. The entire staff at The Cottages On The Key were efficient, knowledgeable and very helpful and ensured we had a great time. I would highly recommend using these guys for your visit to SK!

"Casa Mahalo"

by Brittnee


Prompted by the email asking for feedback, I wanted to share how much we enjoyed our stay at Casa Mahalo (5235U). I work in a client-facing role, so I'm always interested and mindful of how companies/businesses operate in terms of catering to client needs. I was really impressed by The Cottages approach as servicing your guests. Each touch point along the way - from the quick responses and help prior to arriving, emails during our stay to check in and quick responses post-vacation. The team is excellent. Sara and Fabiana were outstanding. Sara couldn't have been kinder and more helpful leading up to our stay and addressing any and every question I had, as well as Fabiana, who went above and beyond to hand-deliver two boxes we had shipped to the office prior to our visit and also was always quick to respond to questions as I was planning and following our stay. They were lovely to interact with! The customized cupcakes upon arrival were such a sweet, unexpected gesture that really elevated our stay from day one, followed by the drop in from Jojo to deliver the bottle of wine. So smart, so nice! We had an AMAZING time. Siesta Key is stunning. The unit was exactly what we had hoped for, and the pool area was amazing. The home was well-equipped with items for the beach, which made our stay THAT much better. Your team was fantastic. We will absolutely be back! Thank you!

"Casa Mahalo"

by PJ W.


We had a fantastic time. Fishing was awesome. I cooked the snapper for dinner last night and it was delicious. Thank you again for a fantastic stay.

"Family vacation"

by Brianne C.


We recently stayed with 3 adults and 4 children and were blown away with the amount of space we had!! Plenty of bedrooms and bathrooms and an amazing kitchen. The kids loved the pool and the adults loved sitting outside and grilling. The garage fridge was such a treat to be able to store grilling foods in. And the property was very well stocked with plenty of beach towels and gear! We will definitely book again!!

"Location, Location, Location"

by Tom B.


Clean, new, spacious, well-stocked, and a short walk to everything.

"Beautiful place"

by Karen H.


Beautiful home. Has everything you might need. Location can’t be beat. We were able to walk everywhere. Highly recommend this place.

"Dear Jojo and the cottage management "

by Hung N.


Dear Jojo and the cottage management You guys are top notch in your business for what you do, above and beyond all my expectations, I did gave my review as soon as when I got home following the link on my email, there’s no 6 so I can only give it 5 stars:) Don’t know why VRBO app doesn’t show my review by the way.

"What can I say, you guys are top notch , you have our wow impressions, love the place"

by Hung N.


Above and beyond my expectation, thanks Jojo n the management, your thoughtfulness to the little things greatly appreciated

"Amazing house!"

by Jen Roller


We came for a wedding and it was the perfect house, awesome location with great amenities. Can’t wait to come back again!

Property is not available for the selected dates
Book Now